RBR Reading Room: Coach Tommy of the Crimson Tide

At Coach Paul W. Bryant's funeral in 1983, Ohio State coach Woody Hayes noted that "Rockne was the great coach of his era and Bryant was the great coach of his." Frank Thomas was the great coach that connected them.
That there is no authoritative biography of this legendary Alabama football coach borders on criminal. About the only tome to be found is a slim volume penned by sportswriter Naylor Stone in the mid-1950s almost immediately after his death, Coach Tommy of the Crimson Tide. In just 86 pages it attempts to circumscribe the career of a man who led the Crimson Tide to no less than two National Championships and three undefeated seasons.
In fact, if remembered at all today, Coach Thomas tends to be recalled for his role mentoring Bryant as a player and a coach. Still, it's worth noting that while Coach Thomas has been almost completely eclipsed by his famous protege, he never suffered a single losing season during his career – something Coach Bryant was not able to boast.
Coach Thomas himself was the protegee of Knute Rockne. Playing for Notre Dame in the 1920s with the famed "Four Horsemen" and George Gipp who was his roommate during college. Coach Rockne called Thomas the smartest player he ever coached and, unsurprisingly, hired him as an assistant after the younger man's playing days were done.
It’s through Rockne, that Coach Thomas found a particular manner to lead his charges later and a particular genius for winning mid-game strategy changes. Both attributes he passed down to his most famous pupil.
One particularly interesting aspect of Thomas’ career is his time as an assistant at Georgia under George Woodruff. When Coach Thomas took over at Alabama he brought the Notre Dame Box offense with him but, it turns out, he had already introduced it to southern football at Georgia while serving as backfield coach for the Bulldogs.
The offense became synonymous with Crimson Tide football due to the team's success under Coach Thomas but it certainly wasn't unique to the region's teams by the time he implemented it in Tuscaloosa.
While Coach Tommy of the Crimson Tide is an important snapshot into an oft-overlooked era of Alabama football, often reads like an overlong newspaper fluff piece from the period. It relies on interviews with both Coach Thomas and his wife but little else. There is little inkling of the charisma and leadership of the man that pressed so heavily on Coach Bryant and molded the latter’s legendary leadership style.
In fact, there’s little of anything in terms of the man’s personality outside of glowing reports of each season and a dultiful accounting of his civic work. But that’s at least partially forgivable given the fact the book was written so shortly after the coach’s death.
There is little inkling of the man that had such a reputation for toughness that a young Paul Bryant was terrified of him. "Scared of him? You're damn right I was." Bryant later confessed. In The Last Coach, Thomas is described by Bryant as having an "aloof, imperious way" that left as lasting impression on the young man as much as his tactical expertise. But almost none of this is evident in Coach Tommy of the Crimson Tide.
And, since the book was published in 1954, Bryant is an ancillary aspect of the narrative at best. The future Crimson Tide coach doesn’t appear at all in the first third of the book and when he does make his entrance it’s by last name only. Eventually, he’s duly noted for his exploits as a player (particularly the infamous Tennessee game he played with a "bad" leg) and as an assistant on Coach Thomas’ staff.
If nothing else, the book does a valuable service in showing the stature of the Alabama program and the tradition of a championship-caliber team that preceded the Bryant Era. But the most important legacy of Coach Tommy of the Crimson Tide is how clearly it demonstrates the need for a definitive book examining the career of this oft-overlooked championship coach.
Next week: The Junction Boys
0 recs |
9 comments
|
Comments
One of the coolest things I've ever seen...
Frank Thomas’ playbook as a quaterback under Knute Rockne. Very interesting.
"There's a lot of blood, sweat, and guts between dreams and success" - Coach Bryant
by TopDaddy on Jun 30, 2009 12:06 PM CDT reply actions 0 recs
that is seriously impressive. great find.
by kleph on Jun 30, 2009 12:20 PM CDT up reply actions 0 recs
And a very nice writeup on the book...
I love learning about the great coaches like Knute Rockne, and his impact on Frank Thomas, and his impact on The Bear and so on. College football history intrests me to no end, as it should anyone who wants to claim national championships from the 1920’s.
"There's a lot of blood, sweat, and guts between dreams and success" - Coach Bryant
by TopDaddy on Jun 30, 2009 1:08 PM CDT up reply actions 0 recs
And obviously...
a “quaterback” is similar to a “quarterback”…
"There's a lot of blood, sweat, and guts between dreams and success" - Coach Bryant
by TopDaddy on Jun 30, 2009 1:04 PM CDT up reply actions 0 recs
Great piece, Kleph...
… I tell you, it’s really amazing how little our fanbase now knows about Thomas. When he was at Alabama, he was more loved than Wallace Wade ever was, and after he retired, the talk for a decade was that we would never find another Frank Thomas. And now six decades after his death, hardly anyone in the fanbase knows anything about him.
I do find the "never find another like… " talk pretty interesting, because us Alabama fans have heard that since Bryant retired. Obviously, though, it seems like we have another top-end coach after all, so that prediction is going the way of the Thomas talk. On the other hand, though, it really does make you wonder just how long it will be before Bryant fades from the fanbase’s collective memory.
by outsidethesidelines on Jun 30, 2009 2:49 PM CDT reply actions 0 recs
Dude...
…we’ll never find another CNS….
by NiceLittleSaturday on Jun 30, 2009 3:38 PM CDT up reply actions 0 recs
that’s very along the lines of what i was thinking when i chose to review this book. because, as i mention, this is about the only book on the man i could find – and not only is is pretty damn anemic it’s also out of print. still, you don’t have to dig too deep into barra’s The Last Coach to get a sense of how important thomas was to bryant’s development and thereby for alabama football.
i don’t think bryant will ever fade in the collective memory of the fanbase because of 1) the sheer scale of his achievements as a coach and 2) the fact his influence went far far further than the football program. for example, stallings was a superb coach and garnered a championship with one of the greatest defenses we’ve ever put on the field but he didn’t even dent bryant’s legacy. but the degree bryant overshadows his predecessors is seriously regrettable.
the problem is that unlike wade, whose career at duke keeps the importance of his achievements alive in at least one fanbase, thomas is now just “another one of those statues next to bryant” for many. and that’s regrettable because while his influence on bryant is important, his influence on Alabama football – even college football as a whole – is actually very profound. while an able and shrewd strategist, bryant was never hailed as an innovator to the game the way his mentor was.
our foes tend to reduce our devotion to the traditions into the handy target of bryant and, due to his importance, that tends to be pretty effective. but alabama football had a strong legacy as champions and a national force in college football over the six decades before bryant took the reins. that bryant has almost completely enveloped the six decades since then is no reason to overlook the prior achievements of the football program completely.
by kleph on Jun 30, 2009 4:52 PM CDT up reply actions 0 recs
While...
…it’s amazing that Bryant owns half of our national championships, there are obviously six others that were earned without him at the helm. Furthermore, as much as we hear about the 1966 team deserving a national title (and they did), the 1945 team under Thomas was no less deserving, and may have been the best team to ever wear the crimson and white. Stallings may have been a “superb” coach, but his legacy doesn’t touch the one Thomas left. You’re dead on in saying that Coach Tommy deserves much more.
by NiceLittleSaturday on Jun 30, 2009 10:19 PM CDT up reply actions 0 recs
and national championships are just a single criteria. thomas’ record holds up well on just about any evaluation you’d like to scrutinize it by.
by kleph on Jun 30, 2009 10:48 PM CDT up reply actions 0 recs

by 





















