Navigation: Jump to content areas:


Pro Quality. Fan Perspective.
Login-facebook
Around SBN: Dog Football! Which Breeds Are Best Suited For The Gridiron?

Sports Columnists Favorite Villain: Nick Saban

When Coach Nick Saban got up on the podium at SEC Media days and uttered the "P" word before a live microphone you could almost hear the nation's sports columnists suck in their breath in excitement. The college football off season is excruciatingly long and it's hard to find material to fill the demands for copy. But with one four letter word  a whole week of material suddenly appeared.

Now a number of sports columnists used Coach Saban's statements to highlight the issue in question: that there are a lot of unscrupulous agents working on the fringes of college football and the proper authority to deal with them needs to get it's butt in gear and take care of the problem. (The Huntsville Times' Mark McCarter had a particularly well-done column about the issue.)

But, of course, crafting a well-reasoned article that lays out the issues and presents them in an objective manner for the reader is.... well, work. And it's a hell of a lot easier -- not to mention more popular -- just to crank out a couple hundred words to bash Coach Saban and hit the bar to yuk it up with a bunch of clowns who will spend the night telling you how great a writer you are (see? cheap generalization as a literary device - so easy anybody can do it!).

Sadly, a fair number of columnists took this route. WARNING: The following links contain excessive amounts of stupid:

The sloppy logic fueling all these columns is pretty much the same. Coach Saban makes $4 million a year and is criticizing a group of people whose profession is representing athletes in their attempts to make that kind of money in the pros. Ergo, he is a hypocrite. Which is arguable in itself (and a fantastic example of the ad hominem fallacy) but becomes ludicrous when the deliberate misrepresentations of Coach Saban's statements are revealed.

Each and every one of these writers deliberately misrepresents Coach Saban's pimp statement as directed at all agents. It wasn't and even a cursory look at the tape shows this. The agents Coach Saban has a problem with are those deliberately acting in violation of the NCAA's restrictions for player-agent contact and the rules laid down by the NFLPA.

Yet from that faulty premise these hacks compound their stupidity by conveniently overlooking the fact that the actions of these unscrupulous agents could cost the student athletes untold millions if this illegal contact affects their eligibility. Add lots of one sentence paragraphs (preferably featuring rhetorical questions) and VOILA! you've just written a nationally circulated sports column.

The facts of the situation tell a much different story than these writers would have you believe. Under Coach Saban, the policy for handling sports agents at University of Alabama has been recognized as an outstanding example of how a program can work to the benefit of all involved. The Crimson Tide football program is regularly cited as one of the most open to agents as well as scouts for professional teams -- policies that only improve player's chances at the next level.

This approach is designed to ensure student athletes are able to retain their eligibility while having an opportunity to make the proper decision on who will represent them as a professional. And no, it's not a completely altruistic enterprise. The better the program is at getting its star players big payoffs in the pros, the better it will be at enticing five-star recruits to come play in Tuscaloosa.

But schools can only do so much to deal with the bad apples among the agents, they have to have help from the NFL -- both the league and the player's association. And Coach Saban's outburst was deliberately designed to get their attention rather than appeal to the hyper-populist moral sensibilities of the nation's sports columnists.

And, in the end, it's the former that will make a difference for the game long after the latter is reduced to used fish wrap.

Comment 43 comments  |  0 recs  | 

Do you like this story?

Comments

Display:

Didn't even read all of the links yet...

But FIRST what the heck does Saban making $4M a year have to do with anything? It’s a lame excuse to to rag on him – jealous idiots. Second, Jeff Shultz’s title is simply misleading and a complete lie. He indicates that Saban is “suddenly” interested in this showing that he knows NOTHING and is completely ingnorant of what Saban has been doing at Alabama and in fact of what the SEC has been doing. People who have no knowledge of sports should not be paid to write about it.

Bama's Pluck and Grit have Writ Her Name in Crimson Flame

by TideFanAtlanta on Jul 25, 2010 11:35 AM CDT reply actions  

Exactly.

As I told the trojans, Alabama has been getting screwed by dirtbag agents since Reggie Bush was in diapers.

What you're seeing is team spirit. It's like the Holy Spirit, but more powerful.

-Hank Hill

by Zoltar on Jul 25, 2010 11:49 AM CDT reply actions  

Oh, their opinions are shared by others

Mostly the large city sports reporters who only look at headlines of other stories to pick up what is going on away from their favorite NFL, NBA, or MLB team. The guys who focus on boxing half of the time on 790 am in Atlanta said similar things.

As for Dodd…. well, he’s never been the type to let the truth get in the way of a good story.

Fumbles. It was always Fumbles

by DocFumbles on Jul 25, 2010 11:58 AM CDT reply actions  

this presumes he's ever written a good story

which i highly doubt given the samplings of his work i’ve had the misfortune of encountering.

Roll 'Bama Roll: The Champagne of 'Bama Blogs.

by kleph on Jul 25, 2010 12:00 PM CDT up reply actions  

It feels good to be hated, doesn't it?

Let them keep it up, while Bama just keeps winning and getting the program where it needs to be.

Roll Tide!

"There's no substitute for guts."

by SoundCheckMama on Jul 25, 2010 12:10 PM CDT reply actions  

A Pimp is inherently exploitative

They are middle men that make money off of getting talent to a buyer. A coach develops and enhances talent. There is no comparison with regards to their specific function. I think what a lot of these guys have is a desire to speak to the hypocrisy and complexity of a “amateur” sport that makes millions for the Universities. That is a legitimate issue, but these guys aren’t attempting an institutional analysis. What they’re writing is a joke.

By the looks of things, I'm pretty sure God doesn't care how you do in sports.

by zarahoopstra on Jul 25, 2010 12:34 PM CDT reply actions  

more to the point...

saban is not saying all agents are specifically exploitative in this manner. in fact, he went out of his way to distinguish between the reputable agents that work within the rules and the ones creating problems for everyone. but these writers deliberately blurred or even flat out ignored that distinction in order to blast saban.

there is a real moral question about the fact that the university and the sport (not just the coaches) benefit handsomely from the players who are essentially regulated into poverty by the ncaa. but painting this specific issue with that brush is dishonest, disingenuous and disheartening for those of us who would like to see these problems addressed.

Roll 'Bama Roll: The Champagne of 'Bama Blogs.

by kleph on Jul 25, 2010 12:39 PM CDT up reply actions  

They are deliberately misconstruing his statement

Absurdly so, because Saban was contrasting the attitudes of agents versus the coaching staffs. The latter seek to fully develop the players – mentally, emotionally, morally, as well as athletically – and give them a brighter future as persons as well as wage-earners. Agents – at least those Saban was referencing – are no better than pimps because they do not ultimately care about the athlete as a person. They merely want to make money off his “services.”

XBL Rep: 96% avoided you.

by Hillbilly Lawya on Jul 25, 2010 2:17 PM CDT up reply actions  

Pathetic rubes..

these fools forget that coaches get paid to develop talent into future millionaires..much like professors do. Most of these assholes have no clue what’s been going on here, anyway. As demonstrated by most “sportswriters” , if they don’t like the looks of the bandwagon,(or, have no personal attachment) they bash to make up for being eunuchs.

"...because you've got your mind right, and that's the way we like it." Nick Saban

by SRGBama on Jul 25, 2010 12:46 PM CDT reply actions  

Agreed.

Not having time just yet to read all the articles or look at the full transcript of Saban’s comments, I’ll just make one more point of comparison on sports agents. They’re a little different than say, literary agents. A writer can’t even get a book seen by a major publisher without going through an agent in today’s market. The agent themselves help develop the writing (through editors) and find a new writer a home in a very complex and confusing industry. Not saying that they’re aren’t a lot of good sports agents that don’t guide these young men’s careers and help them along in life, but the sports world is different in that a lot of these guys are just signing a contract with a team that has already scouted and offered a prospect. That kind of environment attracts a lot of hype men. The kind of guys that look up to Don King as a real winner and put money ahead of the careers and reputations of whom they represent. Frankly, a lot of them do resemble pimps and they will do just about anything for that big easy payday. When I heard the comment it seemed pretty obvious what Saban was getting at, but I’m not surprised at the reaction. Hopefully this might at least stimulate a more reasonable discussion on the relationship between the NCAA and NFL teams.

By the looks of things, I'm pretty sure God doesn't care how you do in sports.

by zarahoopstra on Jul 25, 2010 1:01 PM CDT reply actions  

the pimp comment also makes a lot more sense

when viewed in light of what we have discovered about how marcell was lured to miami.

Roll 'Bama Roll: The Champagne of 'Bama Blogs.

by kleph on Jul 25, 2010 1:03 PM CDT up reply actions  

Yes, and the fact that Saban just fell short of actually defending Marcell

tells you something. If you really listened to CNS and GMAC at media days, you have to believe that if Marcell made a mistake, it was just going down there in the first place. GMAC even said that MD is “a good guy and he is smart”. Very telling to hear that from the smartest player we have had since Pat Trammel. I am just wondering how long it will take for the entire story to come out and a NCAA decision.

Bama's Pluck and Grit have Writ Her Name in Crimson Flame

by TideFanAtlanta on Jul 25, 2010 1:44 PM CDT up reply actions  

i'm not so sure about that...

given the fact the compliance office and the ncaa were doing their “investigation thang.” there really wasn’t much more saban could say concerning the case. but reading meaning into what the man didn’t say is probably going a bit far with conjecture anyway. and lord knows we don’t want the aforementioned hacks heading off into that bold frontier.

Roll 'Bama Roll: The Champagne of 'Bama Blogs.

by kleph on Jul 25, 2010 1:47 PM CDT up reply actions  

Amen. Most modern sports columnists have devolved into cheapshot artists . . .

and really poor ones at that. I perused a few of these and it is classic ad hominen: Saban is a bad guy (because the media horde has decided that is the case because he went to Alabama), ergo any thing he says can be ridiculed.

Their assumptions don’t stand up to scrutiny (among many other lies in their columns is the “Saban blew the roof off college salaries” — when he took a pay cut to come back to college football and essentially came back for the same money Skip Bertman was paying him at LSU;) and they don’t square with how Saban runs his programs (every college president in the country would hire Saban in a heartbeat).

Finebaum has turned himself into a multimillionaire refining cheapshot journalism but at least he has a twinkle in his eye — these other blowhards are just putting out garbage. But they will be “processed” just like Saban processed the late great Smirk of the Plains — with every passing day these cowards will lose the guts to cheapshot Saban and will just go sniveling off into the corner.

by wey on Jul 25, 2010 1:14 PM CDT reply actions  

But they will be "processed" just like Saban processed the late great Smirk of the Plains — with every passing day these cowards will lose the guts to cheapshot Saban and will just go sniveling off into the corner.

the brutal fact that the worst excuse for a journalist and sports writer, furman bisher, is revered as the “dean of sports journalism” is sad proof that this is an overly optimistic assessment. shitty sports columnists tend to thrive while folks doing good work are often lost in the tumult of bullshit.

Roll 'Bama Roll: The Champagne of 'Bama Blogs.

by kleph on Jul 25, 2010 1:20 PM CDT up reply actions  

There have always been cheapshot sportswriters . . .

like Bisher (and I thought of him as an exception when I did the first post) but I don’t remember it being the modus operandi of the profession. I have lived in Chicago, NYC, and DC among other places before the rise of the internet and there was a sense of decorum and fairness with the best writers. Alf Van Hoose and Clyde Bolton were of the old school types here in Birmngham — maybe you didn’t agree with them all the time (I sure didn’t) but they weren’t cheapshot artists. But success in “public” professions often has to do with self promotion and a lot of great writers don’t get ahead because they don’t self promote. Cecil Hurt may be the best sportswriter I have read on a consistent basis and he is old school — but I am afraid that is the exception these days.

But I digress from your point — I still believe the cheapshot sportswriters at the end of the day are cowards (because they are basically liars) and they will keep their heads down when a big man is in the room. Heck, even Finebaum shut up in 99 when Mike DuBose went on his magical run. Saban has shut up a bunch of them already and even these guys (who are admittedly playing to their parochial fan bases — just like Bisher was playing to the “we are not Alabama, we are from Atlanta” mentality of his readers) will shut up if he keeps winning.

by wey on Jul 25, 2010 2:28 PM CDT up reply actions  

the weird thing is...

we don’t want them to shut up. we just want them to stop spouting off stupid shit and make the effort produce pieces that seriously examine the issues. because after years of enduring the public embarrassment our head coaches put us through we now have a guy in charge that is running the program the way a top-tier football program should be run.

but there are always going to be things that touch on debate and controversy and now is the time for good reporters asking solid questions and giving thoughtful commentary to the responses. but, instead, they want to act like spoiled brats upset there no good scandals left to bicker over.

Roll 'Bama Roll: The Champagne of 'Bama Blogs.

by kleph on Jul 25, 2010 2:38 PM CDT up reply actions  

And I think that will happen with the better writers

who unfortunately are in the minority. Now the provincial ones will never give it up. Atlanta writers will always go to great lengths to ridicule all things Alabama — hey, their readers “need” to believe they somehow are better than Alabama.

by wey on Jul 25, 2010 2:53 PM CDT up reply actions  

Idiots.....

….. or exploitative sensationalists, either case is sad, and sadder still knowing that many people apparently read them.

This article hit the problem right on the head with the modern press. They’re not interested (at least most of them) in doing the hard work and then being objective enough to present the truth – they’re much more interested in creating a “buzz” and selling copy.

"No man, I majored in Jounalism, it was easier" Joe Namath answering a reporter who asked if he majored in basket weaving

by Slow Hand Row on Jul 25, 2010 1:18 PM CDT reply actions  

These guys are all jokes.

College athletes are slaves? Seriously, over 3/4th’s of these athletes wouldn’t be getting college degrees without their scholarships. Not to mention getting the proper coaching to develop their athletic abilities so they can have the OPPORTUNITIES and PRIVELIGES to make millions. Can someone explain to me how these kids are slaves? And someone already mentioned this, but I’m also confused how Nicks pay has anything to do with his comments…and how his comments have ANYTHING to do with him and his ability to coach. The man wins games, conference championships, and national championships. Out of his three years at Alabama he’s had 2 undefeated regular seasons in the toughest conference in college football, and could’ve easily pulled off three of three being that his 6 losses in the first season were all by 7 points or less – not even taking in to account that he did that with players with bad attitudes, and poor work ethics. It just baffles me how people still have shit to complain or whine about. Especially with his comments. Jump on a guy for saying what EVERYONE else is thinking? These guys should be in Hollywood writing pointless entries about “who’s dating who” and “who’s gay and who’s not?” because they certainly have no business writing about sports.

It's not the will to win, but the will to prepare to win that makes the difference.
-Paul "Bear" Bryant

by bamalover on Jul 25, 2010 2:14 PM CDT via mobile up reply actions  

Add up the salaries of

Rolando McClain, Terrance Cody, Javier Arenas, Kareem Jackson, Andre Smith, and I could go on, and ask yourself how Saban’s $4 million compares to what he got those guys – and he doesn’t get a cut of their salaries! He’s left with is paycheck and the satisfaction that he helped someone else be successful.

"Let's go be champions, boys!" - Greg McElroy

(Formerly SugarBowl93)

by RememberTheRoseBowl on Jul 25, 2010 2:09 PM CDT reply actions  

This is the problem of "Narrative-Based Journalism"

that has taken over all major journalism in our country, not just sports. In this case, anything that Saban says that fits the narrative that “Saban is evil” is highlighted, just made up, or as we see here deliberately misrepresented, and anything that does not fit that narrative is ignored. These journalists are part of the Cult of the Off-Hand Comment, and they worship at the Throne of Dumb.

Awesome article, Kleph.

by crimsontsunami on Jul 25, 2010 2:12 PM CDT reply actions  

thanks

but be ready, according to the narrative we are going to be written of as apologists.

Roll 'Bama Roll: The Champagne of 'Bama Blogs.

by kleph on Jul 25, 2010 2:19 PM CDT up reply actions  

I came across one of those articles

And I smiled.

Because I know the real reason for the attacks. Tis good to be on top.

by cal n on Jul 25, 2010 7:48 PM CDT reply actions  

If only that were the true cause.

Remember, the same thing happened when Saban dared mention 9/11 after our ULM loss. Rival fans and pundits wasted no time claiming that he equated the two. The journos are trying to make a story (how often do you think they get to use the word “pimp”?) and rival fans are just doing what rival fans do.

I'm wrong all the time.

by PeteHoliday on Jul 26, 2010 3:27 PM CDT up reply actions  

well, being on top adds to it in one respect...

it’s hard for haters to rely on their team’s achievements when they are losing arguments.

Roll 'Bama Roll: The Champagne of 'Bama Blogs.

by kleph on Jul 26, 2010 10:29 PM CDT up reply actions  

A little advice

Reading through the literary masterpieces produced by this braintrust of sports writers reminds me of something my daddy used to tell me:

‘Never argue with a fool, they don’t understand logic.’

"You gonna pull those pistols or whistle dixie..."

by figtide on Jul 26, 2010 7:55 AM CDT reply actions  

I've always relied on that advice...

…when bartending or talking to teenagers….

"High standards come from passion within...." --Coach Nick Saban

by NiceLittleSaturday on Jul 26, 2010 3:54 PM CDT up reply actions  

I have a theory about Saban...

regardless of Saban’s exit from Miami ( Ive heard, from unofficial sources, that Saban’s wife Terry hated living in Miami. She is said to be a small town gal. I lived in MIA for 4 years. Didnt care for it.), folks love to hate on Nick.

Every time Saban meets with the press (weekly 10-20 minute variety) he seems to get frustrated with sports reporters questions.

I believe Saban is at heart, an introvert.

He does not seek the limelight like say Mack Brown (awful coach) and others who love the media attention. Saban coaches football teams. He doesnt appear on Dancing with the Stars. And for this I love him.

by tbone57 on Jul 27, 2010 8:31 AM CDT reply actions  

I agree...

…with everything but the ‘(awful coach)’ comment….

"High standards come from passion within...." --Coach Nick Saban

by NiceLittleSaturday on Jul 27, 2010 8:55 PM CDT up reply actions  

i disagree (that he is an introvert)

he has said many times he is an obsessive personality and lives on routine. it’s a hell of a lot easier to control your surroundings in t-town than miami.

Roll 'Bama Roll: The Champagne of 'Bama Blogs.

by kleph on Jul 28, 2010 8:44 AM CDT up reply actions  

CNS...

…has referred to himself as an introvert…but I agree with your Tuscaloosa to Miami comparison.

"High standards come from passion within...." --Coach Nick Saban

by NiceLittleSaturday on Jul 28, 2010 10:30 PM CDT up reply actions  

i'd be interested in the context of how he said it.

the “obsessive” comment was from the 2010 Coach of the Year Clinic and he was explaining how he likes a very set routine and rarely deviates from it. he might mean that he rarely does things outside of his set pattern and thereby doesn’t end up doing particularly flamboyant.

Roll 'Bama Roll: The Champagne of 'Bama Blogs.

by kleph on Jul 29, 2010 9:30 PM CDT up reply actions  

There's no doubt...

…he’s obsessive…

"High standards come from passion within...." --Coach Nick Saban

by NiceLittleSaturday on Jul 30, 2010 7:59 PM CDT up reply actions  

My attitude toward Brown..

changed late last year. He, and McCoy, almost lost the Big 12 Champ game thru poor clock management. Its was totally unnecessary to be quibbling over the one second remaining. And in the BCS Champ game, Brown call t/o with 3:30 remaining in the 4th qtr. Why? Because he had too few players on the field for Bama’s 4 down and 8 yards to go? Hey Mack, too few players on the field is not an infraction. And Bama surely wouldnt fake the punt. It was poor game management by Brown. Thats one reason, the main reason, I had no doubts that Bama would beat Texas. Brown will never outcoach Saban.

by tbone57 on Jul 28, 2010 6:31 AM CDT reply actions  

I've yet...

…to witness Coach Saban getting outcoached by anyone….

"High standards come from passion within...." --Coach Nick Saban

by NiceLittleSaturday on Jul 28, 2010 10:32 PM CDT up reply actions  

Comments For This Post Are Closed


User Tools

Welcome to the SB Nation blog covering the Alabama Crimson Tide.

FanPosts

Community blog posts and discussion.

Recommended FanPosts

Sg_head_small
The Time A Kentucky Fan Saved Me From Being Raped and Murdered

Recent FanPosts

217791_214823878530807_100000095898390_915537_2094248_n_small
So, why are you against Oversigning?
Darth_saban_small
BCS or Plus-One - Which is Actually More Controversial?
Crystal_ball_small
HBO Video Clips From"Namath"
Steamrollerelephant_medium_small
C-USA, Mountain West Combine
Crystal_ball_small
Driving While Asian
Small
New Saftey Rules Suggested by Bama Opponents
57lsu_small
RBR " Don't Forget About Hoops" Random 10
Fum_small
OT: Anyone running in the Mercedes-Benz Marathon?
Small
AP/ESPN saying the Big 10 considering a Plus One

+ New FanPost All FanPosts >

Roll Bama Roll on Twitter


Managers

Disreputable_small Todd

Miltonf-788904_small outsidethesidelines

Kyp2_small Nico2.0

Editors

Kleph_logo_copy_small kleph

Green_small Matt Dover