The Process by the Numbers: Part II - Air Raid
In yesterday's installment of our look at the Alabama defensive strategy by the numbers we noted that opposing teams have tended to throw the ball more against the Crimson Tide and how Coach Saban's defense used that to impact opponents' offensive productivity. But do the numbers tell us anything about how it works?
Lets start where we did yesterday with opponents' pass percentage per down. We already noted that teams facing the Alabama defense are choosing to pass more on first and second down. Yet on the most obvious passing situation, third down, the numbers haven't jumped that much.
In fact, opposing offenses passed 128 times against the Crimson Tide last year -- the exact same number of times they did in 2007. Proportionally, that is just 2% more. Not an overwhelming uptick by any means. (Tables 1, 2 and 3).
While the number of third-down passes may not be dramatically increased, what seems to have changed is the certainty on the part of the defense as to what is coming. The logic here isn't revolutionary. By stopping the run on first and second down (which we looked at yesterday), you know the pass is coming on third.
And Coach Saban isn't exactly secretive about what he has in store when that happens.
"On third down, we will primarily play man-to-man and mix-in some zone and blitzes. We will occasionally play man-to-man and blitz in this situation... We will rush four or more players versus the pass about ninety-percent of the time."
So while the percentage of third down passes Alabama defenses faced last season wasn't a dramatic change from the past few years there was a pretty significant difference in the Crimson Tide's ability to deny opposing offenses to succeed in that situation. Third down conversions are down by almost 30% since 2007 (Table 4).
By forcing teams into situations where it is more likely they will pass, the Alabama defense can better prepare to stop the play. This chart is the real world equivalent of Spencer Hall's humorous one done in the wake of the SEC Championship Game last December.
So when we look at the increasing numbers of passes on early downs and the increased certainty of the coming throws on later downs the outcome is what you might expect. Not only are Alabama defensive backs more likely to get opportunities to wreck their particular style of havoc, they are getting it where they want it and when they are expecting it.
The details of what then ensues are after the jump...
The most dramatic result is that Alabama was No. 1 in the nation for Passes Defended and No. 2 for Passes Broken Up last year (trading spots with Nebraska in the categories). Chart-wise, you get exactly what you might expect (Table 5 & 6).

So, while YPR numbers took a spike last year. I assume this could be attributed to teams playing from behind and forced to the passing game in hopes of catching up. That means more desperation passes and that means more opportunities for the Alabama secondary to instill The Fear in opposing wide receivers and quarterbacks.

With that kind of pressure its no it's no wonder that Mark Barron led the SEC in interceptions last year and was tied for fourth in the nation in the category (Table 6). And, given that he says he's mastered Coach Saban's defense, in all likelihood he'll have a sensational 2010 as well.
"I feel like I can play any position they put me in right now. I know pretty much all of them," he said. "If they felt like they needed to put me in at Money, I can play that, Star, I can play that, safety, left, right, strong or free. I feel like I'm ready for whatever they need me for."
While the massive amount of talent Coach Saban has had at his disposal has been important, they've been able to produce because the system is designed to help them succeed. This is something that should be of some relief to Crimson Tide fans harboring concerns over the lack of experience in the secondary (outside of Mr. Barron, of course).
Still, while opposing offenses may be able to take advantage of the opportunity early in the season, it's highly doubtful the trend to reduced passing productivity against the Alabama defense is going to experience a dramatic turnaround in 2010.
Tomorrow: Catering the Offense for the Opportunity

Tables and Statistics
Table 1: Alabama Opponent First Down Plays
|
Table 2: Alabama Opponent Second Down Plays
|
Table 3: Alabama Opponent Third Down Plays
|
Table 4: Alabama Opponent Third Down Conversions
|
Table 5: Alabama Opponent Receptions
|
Table 6: Alabama Defensive Secondary (Passes Broken Up & Interceptions)
|

Sources
Chris Brown, Smart Football
- Repost: Preview of Nick Saban's Alabama Defense, June 29, 2009
Brophy, Cripes! Get Back to Fundamentals
- Nick Saban: Middle of the Field Safety Coverage Principles (part I); Oct. 5, 2009
- Nick Saban: Middle of the Field Safety Coverage Principles (part II - Cover 3); Oct. 5 2009
- Nick Saban: Middle of the Field Safety Coverage Principles (part III - Cover 1); Oct. 8, 2009
Other
- LSU Defense 2001 (pdf)
- 2010 Coach of the Year Clinic Football Manual
- College Football Statistics (cfbstats.com)
18 comments
|
0 recs |
Do you like this story?
Comments
loving these charts and graphs Kleph
this shit is like office crack for me. Also, Sports-reference.com launched their cfb database today. So much for productivity this morning.
"Yeah, it's Tennessee, that's the way it is sometimes." - Corey Zickefoose, Pulitzer Prize winner and robbery victim
"I feel sorry for people who don't drink. When they wake up in the morning, that's as good as they're going to feel all day." - Dean Martin
by Thomas Walker Esq on Aug 11, 2010 10:20 AM CDT reply actions
Great job, again.
“But do the numbers tell us anything about how it works?” Hell yes.
And you’re right that passing yards alone must be viewed in context. You probably will pass for more yards, once you see attempting to run against us is a waste of effort.
Same logic applies to TX defense stats last year. A good defense, but their sack numbers and run yards allowed only told part of the story. When you’re usually comfortably ahead for the entire 2nd half, and the other team’s given up running the ball…
So, more please!
if you head over to smart football today....
there is a great piece on how to cater your cover three defense to handle four vertical routes. you’ll find it dovetails nicely with brophy’s analysis of coach saban’s cover three i’ve linked to in this series.
Roll 'Bama Roll: The Champagne of 'Bama Blogs.
Here's my thoughts on our
young yet talented secondary.
If you look at our top three CB’s from last season Javier Arenas, Kareem Jackson and Marquis Johnson, I’m not sure many Bama fans would have considered that good news a few years back. Javy is not a typical CB (size), Jackson gave up a ton plays early in his career, and Johson was never thought of as a reliable CB. Those guys turned into solid, dependable CB’s but at the end of the day, i still held my breath everytime a QB passed to any CB not named Arenas.
This year, even though we don’t have a single CB with game experience, IMO the talent there is much higher. They all have great size, speed and obviously have the talent to play the position. We just have to trust that if Saban can take a bunch of CB’s nobody believed in a few years ago and make them stars, he can do the same to guys of greater talent.
"You stay bought into it when you see your opponent sucking air and physically failing and you're still fit and ready and you know you own his ass."- Corey Reamer speaking about Coach Cochran
in many ways this is similar to my mindset...
i don’t see that the question marks about the secondary going into this season are any greater than the concerns going into 2008 and that group set a pretty high standard. if the expectation is they have to perform at 2009-level, that might be unrealistic. but given Coach Saban’s defensive scheme, i don’t believe they have to.
or to put it another way. even if our sky-high turnover margin from 2009 returns to earth, it’s still going to be a force to be reckoned with.
Roll 'Bama Roll: The Champagne of 'Bama Blogs.
agreed..
Let compare this years secondary to last years O-line. We all thought the O-line would struggle and be our weak point, forcing us to pass more…Well, how many games did they go without a holding call? Im pretty sure that streak is still alive…
I have more faith in Saban/ Smarts ability to coach up the secondary than I do Pendry’s abilty to make our Olineman beasts…and thats saying alot since Pendry might is be the best oline coach in the country.
"You stay bought into it when you see your opponent sucking air and physically failing and you're still fit and ready and you know you own his ass."- Corey Reamer speaking about Coach Cochran
I agree
with everything you said. However, the
Jackson gave up a ton plays early in his careerpart still scares me. It’s a great example that raw talent can not immediately fully compensate for inexperience.
Some people say "If you can't beat them, join them". I say "If you can't beat them, beat them", because they will be expecting you to join them, so you will have the element of surprise.
by BamaHadMeAtHello on Aug 11, 2010 11:29 AM CDT up reply actions
like Kleph pointed out above.
If we are expecting this CB group to replicate what last years squad did….we are asking for pain..
And to be honest, until they prove me wrong, i might have more faith in this years group. Green, Jackson and Johnson gave up play after play last year….And they also made a ton. Im gonna wait till they screw up before i worry…
"You stay bought into it when you see your opponent sucking air and physically failing and you're still fit and ready and you know you own his ass."- Corey Reamer speaking about Coach Cochran
Great Job.
I agree the raw talent at CB is better than 2008. However, experience is a big part of the equation and that is why many are concerned. For example, did Marquis Johnson suddenly get faster from 08 to 09? Nope, but he learned, partially through failures in 08, and in the end was a very good DB. We have no significant experience at corner this year.
As much as I hate Auburn I hate Tenn. that much more.
i think the biggest question mark is
Does talent out wiegh experience? Reamer started all of last year, not because he had more talent but because he was dependable as hell…Yet we saw multiple freshman come in a contribute early over upperclassman…
Unfortunately, we won’t know the answer to this question until we actually play a game…
"You stay bought into it when you see your opponent sucking air and physically failing and you're still fit and ready and you know you own his ass."- Corey Reamer speaking about Coach Cochran
i think this is the wrong question
you cater your approach to whether you are top heavy in one or the other but the effectiveness of the overall scheme should be to the advantage no matter what. instead of weighing them against each other, it makes more sense to guage the strength and weaknesses of the other phases of the defense (as quite a few folks have done in citing the promise of our pass rush).
Roll 'Bama Roll: The Champagne of 'Bama Blogs.
i agree...
Saban will adjust his gameplan on who’s actually playing in the game and for that matter who we are playing against but we saw in ‘07 that he’s not going to coddle young players. I remember Jackson playing quite a lot of man when we probably should have played zone. We also played a hell of a lot of 4 man fronts early on cause we didn’t have a Cody/ chapman size NT. Any good coach will cater his attack around what kind of players he has.
That said, this year we really don’t have a choice whether if someone is more talented or has more experience. Cause the truth is, all those guys with experience but less talent are gone. We will sink or swim with the group of CB’s we have.
"You stay bought into it when you see your opponent sucking air and physically failing and you're still fit and ready and you know you own his ass."- Corey Reamer speaking about Coach Cochran
The 2010 defense should still put The Fear into our opponents.
I believe Saban will have the secondary, young & inexperienced though most of them are, very well-schooled. Then it’s down to the mental aspect — how well each one executes on the field.
I predict the D will be very hard-hitting, play a lot of different LBs for experience and energy in pursuit, and put even more effort into forcing turnovers. Of course, that’s already a trademark of Saban’s D.
LET’S KICK IT OFF ALREADY!
I think table 6...
is the most telling. As the players spend more time in the system the more they learn and understand what the coaches are teaching them. Table 6 illustrates this point the best…for me at least.
PBU
is somewhat a function of experience or at least knowing where you are supposed to be. Take Marquis Johnson. He had a ton of PBU because he just got to the place on the field where he was supposed to be.
Interceptions however have a lot to do with with being in the right place but also great hands. For example Javy’s int against Ole Miss. Some guys may be fast, and get to the right place, can jump but don’t catch that well. They could still be a good db if they can tackle etc. but will be low on the int list. Other guys seem to just pick the ball out of the air even one handed.
As much as I hate Auburn I hate Tenn. that much more.
That PBU chart is pretty amazing.
Nearly tripled in the past 3 years. I guess that’s what an immovable offensive line and well coached DBs will get you!

by 





















