RBR Film Room: AJ McCarron Thinks On His Feet
Going into the 2011 season, the biggest question mark hanging over the Alabama Crimson Tide's prospects was the quarterback position. With two inexperienced underclassmen vying for the starting spot, a lot of ink was spilled over how much that hobbled Alabama's hopes for a successful season.
With A.J. McCarron taking over the starter slot with authority against Kent State, the concern turned to how fast it would be until he was ready to face SEC-level defenses. A lot of the playcalling in September was clearly designed to give him time to get comfortable in his role under center but, at the same time, each week he was asked to do a little bit more.
But doing what is asked and limiting mistakes is a heck of lot different than taking command of the quarterback position. During the Tennessee game there were several plays that hint McCarron might be ready to take this next step forward. One of them occurred at the start of the second quarter.
With second down and five to go, the liklihood Alabama would go to the running game seemed pretty good. As they did much of the afternoon, Tennessee put eight men up to counter any attempt by running back Eddie Lacy to move the sticks. Tight End Jeremy Shelley goes into motion before the snap and sets up on the weak side of the line as if he'll be handling blocking for No. 42 downfield.
Once the ball is snapped wide receivers Marquis Maze, Darius Hanks and tight end Brad Smelley shoot off downfield. McCarron gives a play action fake and Shelley joins the OL with protection. Lacy heads upfield into the line in case the Vol's outside linebacker A.J. Johnson tries to shoot through.
When Johnson hangs back, Lacy moves through the line and heads toward the sideline as McCarron's dump-off option. Meanwhile the Tennessee secondary seems to have the Tide wideouts covered deep since McCarron holds onto the ball in the pocket. Then McCarron rears back like he's about to toss it downfield...
...but instead of unleashing the long bomb, he stops at the last moment and begins to scramble as the pocket starts to collapse around him. UT's Johnson has moved forward to cover Lacy in case McCarron seeks his safety valve so the Tide signal caller starts to improvise.
Seeing Lacy covered he heads out toward the sideline as if he's gonna scramble for what he can to make third down more manageable. UT's Johnson, seeing the Tide QB out in the open and oh-so-ripe for a hard hit leaves Lacy and heads in for the kill.
Then, instead of scrambling out of bounds or throwing the ball away wildly, McCarron draws up and lofts the ball to the now open Lacy standing on the first down line.
The Tide tailback then grabs and extra few yards after the catch and, since this is Tennessee, got hit with a cheap shot by No. 97 Malik Jackson. No matter what happens, don't ever change, Vols.
The play is a nice example of McCarron "creating" and opportunity with his feet when the opposing defense wasn't giving him very much to work with. Instead of settling for not making a mistake, he responded by making the situation work to his advantage.
Did McCarron knowingly lure Johnson forward to uncover Lacy? That's difficult to say. But what is important is he recognized the opportunity when it was presented and used it effectively. And this wasn't an isolated incident. On at least one other play Saturday night McCarron reacted in a similar manner. That a very positive sign for the Crimson Tide going forward.
32 comments
|
0 recs |
Do you like this story?
Comments
I noticed the same thing...
I was impressed with his patience and creativity on several plays. But I couldn’t help thinking to myself, “He’s not going to have time to do that against LSU”. The OL gave him a lot of time against UT, but LSU’s DL is much better.
IDK,
If West Virginia was able to protect their QB pretty well, we might can do the same.
"Think of how stupid the average person is, and realize half of them are stupider than that." - George Carlin
by Slice of Life on Oct 26, 2011 3:45 PM CDT up reply actions
these screencaps and video
also offer a nice opportunity to see how well the OL is performing.
Remember the Rose Bowl: The Story of the Alabama Crimson Tide & the Grandaddy of Them All
Yeah,hard to believe.
They played like all stars versus the corndog defense,and like pop warner versus Syracuse.
RBR resident Dogcaller.
by Crimsoncaller on Oct 26, 2011 7:02 PM CDT up reply actions
We have a rich recent history . . .
of QBs not using the time they have.
Croyle was not good at looking off his primary. Wilson was even worse; it was like he didn’t even know there was more than 1 receiver out there. McElroy was better than either of those guys, but not very good; whenever he started running, well, he ran. The concept of running to an open spot to set up and look downfield was foreign to him.
McCarron is hands-down better at buying time and looking for another receiver than any QB we’ve had at least since Tyler Watts, and probably back well before that. Hands down.
ha
Well it’s obvious youre one of the fans in a love affair with AJ…I will tell you right now if he doesn’t run the ball more to get positive yards when it’s there it will hurt the team. LSU doesn’t respect him at all as far as taking off and they know he won’t run it so look for them to pin their ears back and bring everything. AJ needs to do a better job of assessing the coverage and making a faster decision especially against LSU. If the obly thing open is a 7 yard run then at least Greg would pick it up, AJ refuses to and it causes sacks.
by #1BamaNation on Oct 27, 2011 9:45 AM CDT up reply actions
If it's not the obly thing...
…I’m OK with turning an easy pass into a first down while not subjecting himself to injury….
"High standards come from passion within...." --Coach Nick Saban
by NiceLittleSaturday on Oct 27, 2011 9:48 AM CDT up reply actions
I don't agree with the idea . . .
that a QB needs to run out of the pocket to loosen the D. Pretty sure it’s the other way around. If the D knows the QB will keep looking around and find a guy who breaks open late it means they have to keep covering the entire field the entire play. If McElroy started rolling out you could definitely loosen up your coverage and unless you were standing right in front of him you could pretty much abandon coverage and just come after him, because you know he’s gonna run.
AJ did run for a TD Saturday night, if you will recall, and has run for first downs previously, so it ain’t like he never runs. But the run out of the pocket should be the last option unless there is a big wide-open hole to run into. The percentages are always better if you scramble out of the pocket and then look downfield. By that time, receivers have had extra time to get open, and they should be open if they’re any good. Throws off the scramble tend to work very well if they’re accurate.
Also, re my “love affair” with AJ: I don’t think my personal sentiments are really relevant to whether he is a good QB, but just for the record I was on the Sims train big-time after AJ and right up to the Kent St. game. And I bitched about AJ a lot the first few games. But he has improved on a week-by-week basis. He is a very good QB now, probably already better than either McElroy or Wilson ever was, and still improving week-to-week.
Better than McElroy ever was?
Hmmm…I hope so…




"High standards come from passion within...." --Coach Nick Saban
by NiceLittleSaturday on Oct 29, 2011 9:41 AM CDT up reply actions
Great article...agreed.
He also did this down on the goal line with a nice throw to Smelley that was a key play on that drive. True that other DLs will be a lot better, but just that he has the ability to create like that is a good sign – especially relatively early in his career.
I think AJ has a lot more upside than some of the QBs we’ve had in the past.
by Richard Rodgers on Oct 26, 2011 3:30 PM CDT reply actions
That's the one that I noticed the most
the one Kleph breaks down was a good job by AJ, but his best one of the day was that one to Smelley….and he was fired up after he did it – he probably got a “calm the f^*& down” from Coach Saban when he looked across the field at the sideline – but it was a great job by a young QB, to first avoid a rusher that was in his face almost immediately on the snap, and then to throw a perfect touch pass while running left and throwing across his body…..I really think AJ is going to be something else when he has some more experience….
one of the reason we chose this play
(and i say “we” because OTS and Todd and I all discussed the play to use in this post) was because it was not one of the premier plays of the game. this play was so mundane it didn’t even get a replay right afterward. it was just another down mover in the middle of a first half that wasn’t spectacularly interesting. but the pattern of good decisions is really what matters and this is the first good example of a game that featured a series.
Remember the Rose Bowl: The Story of the Alabama Crimson Tide & the Grandaddy of Them All
Good point
as the one I was referring to and this one were very similar in that the protection broke down quickly, and AJ made good athletic plays on both in order to get the ball to our playmakers….It will be interesting to watch and see how good AJ can be as he matures…
I forgot about that late hit.
Bastards.
"Think of how stupid the average person is, and realize half of them are stupider than that." - George Carlin
Not so much forgot than expected.
"There's a lot of blood, sweat, and guts between dreams and success." -Coach Bear Bryant
"I thInk everybody should take the attItude that we’re workIng to be a champIon, that we want to be a champIon In everythIng that we do. every choIce, every decIsIon, everythIng that we do every day, we want to be a champIon."
-- Nick SabaN
by Tokeisch on Oct 26, 2011 4:47 PM CDT via mobile up reply actions
Yeah, I didn't even see it before,
but it was pretty obvious. They low down. They dirty.
God bless our Dark Lord.
He's lying on the ground...
…so I would have appreciated an earlier whistle from the ref. Still a dumb decision by 97….
"High standards come from passion within...." --Coach Nick Saban
by NiceLittleSaturday on Oct 27, 2011 9:49 AM CDT up reply actions
Really enjoy these cut-ups
Thanks for putting in the time; this is an example of the kind of quality offered on this site.
Can’t wait to see what you use when we beat LSU.
RTR
Good choice of a play to break-down Kleph
as well as a good analysis. I also liked the play call/blocking/route running on the Michael Williams play in the end zone. Of course, AJ overthrew him which led to the 2nd field goal (I think). I’m hoping AJ got all of his wide-open-overthrows and interceptions out of his system heading into LSU.
Mark Barron, y'all.
I've been pretty critical of AJ, and he still frustrates me.
However, this play and the pass to Smelley where he also scrambled a bit have shut me up. AJ plays hard, he’s got talent, and he wants to win. What else could I ask for?
Audemus jura nostra defendere
Every day we make it, we'll make it the best we can.
As these photos show
AJ held the ball too long in the first half. Lucky he found his outlet receiver.
He was a different QB in the second half.
I have to differ on that
He held on to the ball just the right amount. He waited for the guy to break open, and then he hit him. He did that several times in this game. I was very impressed. We haven’t seen a QB doing that in Tuscaloosa in quite some time.
What cheap pounce shot
by that Vile guy. Did we pay the refs to not call that, just to make things look to be on the up and up? Yeah, that’s the ticket.
"I never did give anybody hell. I just told the truth and they thought it was
hell."
- Harry S Truman
We're through the looking glass here, people.
Rammer Jammer Yellow Hammer Give 'Em HELL Alabama!
by RoscoeOfAlabama on Oct 26, 2011 7:44 PM CDT up reply actions
did you do these break downs last year?
i don’t remember them, but man have i enjoyed them this year. excellent stuff. am i the only one that thinks we are going to start rolling AJ out on designed plays? he’s just better on his feet. i think it takes the adrenaline down enough for him to not overthrow everyone by 15 yards.
we didn't do this much last year
but you can find the archive of these posts here.
Remember the Rose Bowl: The Story of the Alabama Crimson Tide & the Grandaddy of Them All
Never knew about Shelley's position change
Did he bulk up some during the season? Cause he’s listed at 165 on the roster, and that’s a little small for a tight end.
There was another nice ad lib from AJ (just to add)
Maybe early in the 3rd qtr? cant remember exactly. He rolled right when the play called wasnt working. TR was blocking on the right side. When TR saw AJ (no periods) roll right, TR released his block and turned around to see AJ dropping a short dump off pass his way. Gained about 15 yds and a first down. Very impressed with several on-the-fly decisions made by AJ in instances where TN had done a great job covering the play. It must be frustrating to a D when you do all the right things and still get torched. Im betting the coaches really like what they see from AJ, even with the silly INT to start the game.
Proud mini-Saban.

by 

































