RBR Film Room: Special Teams Trickeration
Alabama has seemingly always had a tendency for big plays early in games against Arkansas, going back to Shaud Williams in 2002, and that has been especially true under Nick Saban. After Glen Coffee gutted the Hogs in 2008 in Fayetteville, two years ago Alabama jumped out to another early lead over Arkansas thanks in large part to some trickeration on a long pass play out of the Wildcat. When Bobby Petrino and company returned to Tuscaloosa this past weekend, Saban pulled off the trickeration yet again, this time with a shift out of a field goal formation. Let's take a closer look at the film.
Alabama starts the game with two Trent Richardson rushes that net the Crimson Tide 30 yards, and the chains keep moving with a twelve-yard completion to senior wide receiver Marquis Maze. 'Bama looks poised to continue the early offensive success in Arkansas territory, but the drive immediately stalls. Richardson gets blown up in the backfield on second down, and on third and long A.J. McCarron finds discretion to be the better part of valor and tucks the football for a four-yard gain, bringing up fourth down. With the ball at the Arkansas 37-yard line, Nick Saban sends Cade Foster into the game, ostensibly to attempt a 54-yard field goal.
Despite the big leg prep pedigree, however, Foster has been something of a disappointment since arriving in Tuscaloosa, lacking the booming kick-offs many expected and being too inconsistent to beat out Jeremy Shelley for the short-and-intermediate attempts. Through fifteen games at Alabama, the career long for Foster is 49 yards, and the two kicks he has attempted from roughly this distance have landed closer to the back pilons than the goal posts.
Surprisingly though, given the length of the kick and Foster's erratic nature, Arkansas comes out in a field goal block formation with all eleven defenders at least initially feigning some intention of rushing the kick. Bobby Petrino could have played it safe and simply sent his base defense onto the field for the fourth and four, but for whatever reason decided that was not necessary.
Of course, Alabama doesn't stay in the field goal formation for long. Starting quarterback AJ McCarron, who is also the Tide's holder on placekicks, quickly shifts back into the shotgun formation, as tight end Chris Underwood splits out wide and Foster darts out in the slot, both players to the offensive left. McCarron, however, lines up seven yards behind the line of scrimmage, abnormally deep for a quarterback in the shotgun.
Reacting to the shift, though, Arkansas only slightly alters their alignment. Julian Horton goes out wide to cover Underwood, and both Jerry Franklin and Alonzo Highsmith drop off the line and into a two-point stance. Aside from those three players, however, the bulk of the Arkansas defenders make few substantive moves.
Based on the pre-snap look alone, the smart money on this play is arguably a pooch punt from A.J. McCarron. With no one back deep to return for the Razorbacks, McCarron could easily loft a dribbler over the head of the defense and allow it to roll toward the goal line where an Alabama player could easily down the ball to pin the Hogs up deep. Additionally, this would explain the abnormally deep alignment of McCarron in the shotgun, who would be looking for extra room to launch a punt if indeed that were the call.
When Chris Underwood darts across the formation to the offensive right, though, it becomes more and more clear that no pooch punt is coming from the Tide.


By the time that Underwood makes his way across the formation, some five full seconds have elapsed since Alabama originally shifted out of the field goal formation. Bobby Petrino sits on the sideline with three timeouts in his proverbial back pocket -- one of which will ultimately go unused in the first half -- and does nothing while the Arkansas defense worriedly glances back and forth at one another in obvious confusion over what is transpiring.
When the football is snapped, notice how everything (well, almost everything, as we will see) goes to the offensive right.

A.J. McCarron rolls right and retreats some thirteen yards behind the line of scrimmage. Undra Billingsley, the converted tight end who was at defensive end five weeks ago, releases off the line of scrimmage and runs a crossing route over the middle. Foster, too, cuts inside and runs a crossing route of a slightly greater depth than Billingsley. Meanwhile, motion man Chris Underwood turns upfield hard as he crosses the formation and attacks the defense down the right sideline on a vertical route.
And just as it was drawn up, with 'Bama moving everything to the offensive right, the Arkansas defenses flows in the same direction. Meanwhile, Alabama tight end Michael Williams goes unnoticed as he slips behind the offensive line and sneaks out the backside.

Let's flip camera angles for a better view of the action to see just how clean of a release Williams gets while going across the field.


Once around D.J. Fluker, who was lined up at left tackle on this snap, Williams plants his foot in the ground and turns upfield. With the pre-snap motion from Underwood and the crossing routes from Billingsley and Foster, the Arkansas defense has all swarmed to the front side and no one is remains on the backside to cover Williams.
Of all of the Arkansas defense, only junior defensive tackle DeQuinta Jones notices Williams sneaking out the backside, and despite his efforts there is nothing that the Bastrop product can do about it. Jones gives it all he has but Williams is some 40 pounds lighter and he easily pulls away in the footrace as the duo charge upfield.
With Williams wide open and only a bulky defensive tackle trailing him, McCarron is faced with one of the easiest downfield throws he will make during his time at the Capstone. The ball seemingly sails a bit and for the slightest moment the pass looks like it may be overthrown, but having a 6'6 target with good speed has its perks, and Williams aggressively chases the ball and plucks it out of the Tuscaloosa air.
As the afternoon progresses 'Bama dismantles the Hogs vaunted passing attack and pulls away in large part to three more long touchdown plays like this one. The final score indicates a relative snoozer, but nevertheless never underestimate the potential impact of big plays early in games, and with Arkansas looking to establish itself as a national championship contender, 'Bama seizes the early momentum and once again builds an early lead from the outset via the big play.
59 comments
|
0 recs |
Do you like this story?
Comments
it didn't take
long for my professor to discover that I wasn’t looking at his power point presentation…but CBS ’s streaming coverage during class on Saturday. Fake FGs for TD make me happy.
Love the photos
Great breakdown.
Seemed like odd coaching on both sides. On 4th and 4 from the 37, you don’t really expect to fool anybody by bringing out the field-goal kicker who has never hit one from anywhere near this range, so why not just go for it straight up? The percentages obviously say go for it.
Even odder, though, to actually get fooled. And not use your time out.
Looking for Replay
I was at a wedding on Sat. and my recorder didn’t get the game as planned. Does anyone know where I can watch/get a replay of the game online?
Thanks!
"When you win, there's glory enough for everybody. When you lose, there's glory for none." - Paul W. "Bear" Bryant
I was in a car in Arizona and missed it as well
and I have looked for a replay and so far all I found was the one on the sec website (www.secondemand.com), but it costs $4.99 to rent and $8.99 to own.
This is Great!
secondemand.com has a full reply . . . available for free! Just click the “full games” tab and you can get all of the games so far this year. Don’t know where you went to be charged $4.99 to rent.
Thanks!
"When you win, there's glory enough for everybody. When you lose, there's glory for none." - Paul W. "Bear" Bryant
The Arkansas game only has the first 30 seconds for free
Looks like you have to rent the whole game.
Mark Barron, y'all.
by twominutedrill on Sep 28, 2011 2:17 PM CDT up reply actions
Although secondemand.com has the 2009 SECCG
available to view all week for free. That is a good compromise I guess.
Mark Barron, y'all.
by twominutedrill on Sep 28, 2011 2:20 PM CDT up reply actions
SEC Rewind on CBS College
I caught it there and it’s the highlights, basically, without the BS
by Tider1701 on Sep 28, 2011 12:49 PM CDT via mobile up reply actions
Also, can you find your way back to the groom?
And punch him square in the face for having a wedding on a Gameday!! The nerve of some people…
by Tider1701 on Sep 28, 2011 12:56 PM CDT via mobile up reply actions
When you fail to plan
you plan to fail.
"Football has never been just a game to me. Never."
Paul William Bryant
by mr.peabody on Sep 28, 2011 12:58 PM CDT up reply actions 1 recs
My good friend
asked me to be in his wedding November 19, I told him I had to check the schedule first. He thought I was kidding. Lucky for him, we play Ga St. on Thursday that week.
Umm. That was last year.
This year we play Georgia Southern on Saturday…
Dave Robertson is growing up to be the new Mariano Rivera. My two universes of fandom can finally unite!
by SoGladILeftTheACC on Sep 28, 2011 10:51 PM CDT up reply actions
I tried to reason with him...
…I begged even. But he doesn’t care about football and just doesn’t understand. If I wasn’t actually in the wedding I would have just skipped it. If it were anyone else….
"When you win, there's glory enough for everybody. When you lose, there's glory for none." - Paul W. "Bear" Bryant
Replay
If you have Xbox Live, you can probably watch a replay on ESPN 3 there on demand. I know they had both the first two games available.
"Never start a fight with an old man...if he's too old to fight, he'll probably just kill you."
It's not on ESPN3,
since this game wasn’t broadcast on ESPN.
Go to TideTv
There is a full replay there
by Patrick Murphy Sux on Sep 28, 2011 1:40 PM CDT up reply actions
We’ve run a fair amount of fake kicks under Saban, but as best I can recall this is the only one that was actually executed well.
Roll Bama Roll - The Champagne of Bama Blogs.
We can all be happy they used all three timeouts on their first drive
Proud member of the Fax Girl fan club.
by billycthulhu on Sep 28, 2011 5:48 PM CDT up reply actions
I laughed when I saw them line up for the FG.
I didn’t know they were gonna pull the trick play, but I knew they sure as hell weren’t gonna kick that FG.
"Football has never been just a game to me. Never."
Paul William Bryant
I didn't laugh until I saw the shift.
Having watched Foster all year my initial reaction was “WTF is Saban thinking?!” That should have been Petrino’s reaction too and he should have been running down the sidelines calling a timeout. I would love to see film of Petrino as the play developed and the pass was completed.
Yeah same here.....
We were in the stadium and I turned to my dad and said Why are we kicking a 54 yard field goal? We don’t have anybody that can kick a 54 yard field goal…..and right as that came out of my mouth, everybody started shifting and I was immediately nervous as hell – it didn’t even occur to me why Petrino didn’t call a TO – and then I saw Williams streaking open and the ball left AJ’s hand and there was no doubt in my mind that he had overthrown him by 3 or 4 yards – but that ball had some loft on it and it settled right into Williams’ hands and everybody went nuts….
My first thought
when AJ released the ball was that he overthrew Williams. Very relieved when it hit him in stride.
Ha! Glad I’m not the only one, I just knew that was going to be an incompletion.
Roll Bama Roll - The Champagne of Bama Blogs.
Same here 106....
from Section G it looked like he had overthrown him by at least 3 or 4 yards, but I think that it was kind of a high looping throw with some air under it and that’s why it looked that way…..
thanks for the breakdown
the 5 second delay was surreal.
Interesting that Petrino still had 1 time out left at the half.
You would think a coach with his experience would keep track of that.I’m sure he was kicking himself for not calling time out.
RBR resident Dogcaller.
the other reason this is perplexing
is that saban had already made it clear he was going to be aggressive on this possession by taking the ball when alabama won the toss. that usually mean’s he intends to put points on the board first, no matter what it takes. we saw a similar situation with a less productive result in the national championship game.
Remember the Rose Bowl: The Story of the Alabama Crimson Tide & the Grandaddy of Them All
Yeah I too was surprised
when he took the ball. He hardly ever does that.
"Football has never been just a game to me. Never."
Paul William Bryant
I don't know we take the ball first a lot under Saban.
And I’d think we want it first vs. UF if we can get it.
Saban is not the Mr. Conservative everybody thinks and it is actually good everybody thinks that.
If Auburn was in New Mexico and we never played them I would still hate them and their dumb coach and their cheating players.
well, conservative doesn't automatically mean
a lack of aggressiveness. i do consider saban’s approach to be “conservative” in the sense it’s predicated on eliminating errors and minimizing risk. but that’s a useless gambit if you aren’t going to take advantage of the opportunities that approach provides you.
Remember the Rose Bowl: The Story of the Alabama Crimson Tide & the Grandaddy of Them All
Agreed
I mean, it’s not Gus Malzahn or anything out there, but we’re not going to run-run-pass every possession either. His first year here we kicked an onside kick to open the 3SIO game and it worked pretty well. There’s the Maze TD pass from last year, this fake FG play, and I’m sure I’m missing some more somewhere as well.
Proud member of the Fax Girl fan club.
by billycthulhu on Sep 28, 2011 5:51 PM CDT up reply actions
ummm
…cough…fake punt…cough….texas….cough…cold mccoy…cough
Agreed. He doesn’t go all Tubby Tuberville with the trick plays, but he has them in the playbook and uses them at strategic points. Even if they don’t work, they tend to keep the other team wary.
Attempting to remove humor from posts since August 30, 2011
Was that called by Saban though?
I thought that was a read by the punter and not a play called from the sidelines.
Great breakdown.
The tendency on a play like this with a guy so wide open is to almost always put a lot of air under the bal and throw it short. This makes the revceiver stop and wait and sometimes lets even a big defender back in the play. I think it makes th eball harder to catch too. I’m glad AJ had the guts to lead Williams just a bit
If Auburn was in New Mexico and we never played them I would still hate them and their dumb coach and their cheating players.
Gotta give props to that defensive tackle.
He senses something is up almost immediately because he backs off of his rush. He just couldn’t catch up once he found Williams
I watched the first half of this game in my hotel bar in Nashville
I mentioned during the opening drive that I wished the picture was in HD, so the bartender starts fumbling around with the remote to switch to the CBS HD channel. I practically missed the entire play while he was pulling up the menu guide. I told the bartender to stand in that same spot with the remote in his hand until the game is over. Looks like everything turned out okay.
Mark Barron, y'all.
I, too, thought the ball was going to sail on A.J. when it was released...
However, if you look closely at the replay, the ball couldn’t have been thrown any better. It was placed just over the receivers inside shoulder where only he could catch it with semi-extended arms. (even though nobody else was within 5 yards of the receiver).
Perfect execution, perfect throw, etc…
It wasn't the only time either
McCarron has certainly made a few dangerous throws that were luckily not intercepted, but he’s also made some very good throws such as this one. Even on the missed throw to Maze (I think) where it looked like he didn’t have the timing down, he at least threw it so that if Maze didn’t get it, no one else would either.
Proud member of the Fax Girl fan club.
by billycthulhu on Sep 28, 2011 5:54 PM CDT up reply actions
I guess if no one had been open, McCarron might've still had the option to punt the ball, right?
God bless our Dark Lord.
Of course
but would he have been that quick to react?
If Auburn was in New Mexico and we never played them I would still hate them and their dumb coach and their cheating players.
Hopefully, if he had been coached to do so.
GMac said they’d been practicing that for over a year, so I’d assume he knows the wrinkles of that play.
God bless our Dark Lord.
i'm not so sure mccarron punting was ever an option here
as i pointed out in the other thread today, i think the reason he’s so deep in this formation is because the center is carson tinker – a long snapper. putting him closer would just make one more thing that could go wrong in a pretty complex play.
and if you look at how arkansas coverage was botched and try to sort out what would be the correct way to keep williams from scoring, it would seem to leave enough leeway on the left side for aj to make the dash for the first down.
Remember the Rose Bowl: The Story of the Alabama Crimson Tide & the Grandaddy of Them All
Maybe, but I still think he could've punted at the last second if need be, given that there wasn't much pressure on him.
So I don’t see why it wouldn’t be an option. I mean, I’m just asking, but it seems viable to me.
Also, as OTS points out, AJ lined up 8 yards back from the line, and then retreated at least 5 more yards after the snap. Why would he have gone even further back after the snap if his alignment was just due to the snapper? I think maybe it was to make sure he would have room to kick. Maybe.
God bless our Dark Lord.
Maybe Tinker is known for a flatulence problem.
Maybe.
'There are two pains in life. There is the pain of discipline and the pain of disappointment. If you can handle the pain of discipline, then you'll never have to deal with the pain of disappointment,'- Nick Saban
Maybe get some flooring
…stuff like that. Maybe Bed, Bath, & Beyond, I don’t know, I don’t know if we’ll have enough time.
Attempting to remove humor from posts since August 30, 2011
You're my boy, Blue!
'There are two pains in life. There is the pain of discipline and the pain of disappointment. If you can handle the pain of discipline, then you'll never have to deal with the pain of disappointment,'- Nick Saban
This was my dad's play when he coached high school
In fact, I called him in absolute amazement right after the score because it was the first time that I saw it develop live and executed to perfection. Granted, he probably didn’t invent it, but for he and his southern California coaching buddies, it’s his play.
One important clarification: The reason it’s unstoppable isn’t simply the misdirection, though that is schematically key. It’s also that the assigned receiver scrapes behind the line of scrimmage after a beat or two. The D lineman assigned to him tries to follow, but he’s caught up in the wash. And because the play develops so quickly, there’s no time for the assigned defensive player to call out adjustments. As we saw here, by the time someone does realize a receiver has released into the flat and is heading upfield, it’s too late. AJ’s only job was to not screw up the throw.
As for Petrino calling a timeout, that’s debatable. You can’t really guard against this play and his base defense had been working to this point. I think sometimes a team just executes a play perfectly and for that there is no defense.
"That rug really tied the room together."
Clarification on Petrino
The assumption is that he was fooled and I’m not sure that was the case. I think he knew the fake was coming, but just couldn’t stop it.
"That rug really tied the room together."
by pantsfucious on Sep 28, 2011 5:21 PM CDT up reply actions
But couldn't he see that his defense wasn't reacting very well?
They certainly looked confused, and there was a good 5+ seconds between the change in formation and the snap. Even if he knew the fake was coming, the players out there didn’t look prepared, and it seems like Petrino could have gotten things straightened out with a TO, and maybe even force Bama to punt instead of trying for the score.
Proud member of the Fax Girl fan club.
by billycthulhu on Sep 28, 2011 5:56 PM CDT up reply actions
I think he knew the fake was coming, but just couldn’t stop it.
I think that if a timeout were called, Saban would have either punted or ran a play out of a conventional offense.
The main reasons this play worked was because a) the element of surprise and b) the defensive players were confused. There was not enough time to think the situation through and react. A timeout, at the very least, would have allowed the coaches and players time to digest the alignment and change the defense.
by ding ding ding on Sep 28, 2011 6:42 PM CDT up reply actions
The beauty of the play
Is that unless you see it coming, you can’t defense it. Actually, if you drop into zone coverage, it’s more defensible because you can keep the play in front of you. But, Bama could line up in I-formation and switch to the play or they can line up in 5-wide and switch to the play. It can go to the left or right or you can intentionally decoy the play and run it strong-side just to see how the defense reacts to the weak side. One area of the field where I’d love to see it run is on the goal line because the defense doesn’t really have enough space to sit in a zone. Then, when you have that TE or slot back or H-back pulling across the line against the wash, you have man on man and the D is doomed. It’s a perfect play in so many ways.
"That rug really tied the room together."
by pantsfucious on Sep 29, 2011 9:14 PM CDT up reply actions
My wife is looking at me funny right now...
…since I whooped like I did Saturday.
I was almost as tickled as when Penn State called their third timeout earlier in the year. At that point I knew I could start collecting for the ASU tailgate while watching the game.
It's not what you've done but what you are doing that matters.
Make its ass quit -TWEsq to me concerning my fight against Multiple Sclerosis
Well, this proves it.
Nick Saban wears Les Miles pajamas.
2011 LSU Accolades:
"Imperial Intergalactic Overlord Barkevious Mingo" -Andy Staples
"If Alabama's defense is a boa constrictor, slowly sucking the life out of opposing offenses, LSU's is more like a goon that throws the offense into a burlap sack and starts beating it with a stick." -Matt Hinton
"Oregon’s Chip Kelly is generally considered a coaching mastermind. Miles toyed with him here Saturday night." -Dan Wetzel, Yahoo Sports
"I don’t want to say that I think Mo Claiborne is faster than Patrick Peterson…..but I think Mo Claiborne is faster than Patrick Peterson." -Les Miles
honestly
i think he swiped this pair from spurrier after last year’s game in colombia.
Remember the Rose Bowl: The Story of the Alabama Crimson Tide & the Grandaddy of Them All
Wait...
Nick Saban wears Les Miles pajamas
I thought Les wore Elmer Fudd Underoos instead of pajamas? Not only for comfort, but it doesn’t get in the way of the voodoo chicken bone necklace that he wears…
:)
Attempting to remove humor from posts since August 30, 2011
Whoever drew up this play (if not Saban)...
…got a little extra in their paycheck this week. That play worked to perfection.
After the way the Arky defense was panicking, Petrino should have recognized and called timeout.

by 






















