Navigation: Jump to content areas:


Pro Quality. Fan Perspective.
Login-facebook
Around SBN: Bracketology 2012: Duke Finally Steps Up To The No. 1 Line

BlogPoll Calling: Todd's Final Ballot

1. LSU - As much as it may pain me to do it, a tip of the white, goobery hat must be made to LSU. They absolutely destroyed Ohio State, making them look like hapless patsies for the better part of the game and forcing them to play the kind of game virtually everyone knew they were incapable of playing. It's a disatisfying pick for #1 since they are, in fact, a two loss team, but in a season where apparently no one wanted to be #1 and where the title game opponents found themselves selected more by the fortuitous failures of their peers than their own actual merits (strange, I thought we didn't have a playoff in college ball...), we're left with LSU. Even though I can't say I'm happy about their being the 2007 Mythical National Champions, I can say they actually played like it last night, though, so kudos and whatnot.


Anyone else excited about the continuation of the inevitable and endless "Myth of SEC Speed" debate this is sure to engender?

2. Kansas - Didn't win their conference (or division for that matter), but neither did Georgia and the Jayhawks came out with a better record at 12-1.

3. Georgia - It was really a toss up at this point over whether to give UGA the nod at #3 or to go with Southern Cal. Both teams have played phenomenal ball down the stretch, and I seriously considered going with USC since they won (well, split) their conference and Georgia didn't even win the SEC East, but even that, combined with the memories of the inexplicable beatdown by Tennessee and embarassing loss to South Carolina, isn't enough to outstench the odor of a loss to Stanford.

4. USC - Capped off a pretty decent season with a thorough dismantling of Illinois in the Rose Bowl to finish 11-2. Again, could have been #3 (or #1, really) if not for the Stanford loss.

5. West Virginia - Dismantled Oklahoma in the Fiesta Bowl to finish 11-2, but memory of an inexecusable loss ot Pitt to finish the regular season (and to knock them out of contention for the MNC) keeps them from moving any higher than five.

6. Missouri - Had a great season, only losing to Oklahoma (twice), and dominated Arkansas in the Cotton Bowl to finish 12-2.

7. Boston College - They didn't look all that hot against Michigan State in the Champs Sports Bowl, and they had a couple of head scratching losses to FSU and Maryland, but to finish 11-3 under a new head coach is pretty impressive.

8. Texas - Pounded a very good Arizona State team in the Holiday Bowl to finish 10-3. Still, should have done better.

9. Virginia Tech - Finished 11-3 with a close loss to a very good Kansas team in the Orange Bowl. I kind of feel like they should be lower, but there isn't anyone I'd put ahead of them either.

10. Tennessee - An up and down year for the Vols ended with a 21-17 win over a respectable Wisconsin team to end up at 1-4.

11. Ohio State - Go to hell.

12. BYU - An 11-2 season, MWC Champs, and a miraculous (revenge) win over UCLA in the Las Vegas Bowl gets them up to #12.

13. Oklahoma - The Sooners can't buy a BCS win these days, and don't think they haven't tried.

14. Michigan - SEC SPEE...oh wait.

15. Florida - Had a better season than Michigan, but I just can't rank them higher.

16. Auburn - Fittingly, Kodi Burns scored the winning TD while Cox was on the bench. These guys are going to be good next year.

17. Texas Tech - Another year, another rousing comeback to secure a bowl win.


Plus, it gives me an excuse to bring back your favorite and mine, the Texas Tech Swim Team!

18. Cincinnati - Capped off a 10 win season with a victory over Southern Miss right here in the Magic City. Could have had an amazing year, but you just don't lose to Pitt and Louisiville (this year's model anyway) in back to back weeks and expect to be higher than #18.

19. Oregon - Could have gotten to New Orleans had Dixon remained healthy, but instead will have to settle for a 56-21 beatdown of USF in the Sun Bowl to finish up 9-4. I actually fell asleep during that game when the score was something like 3-11 in favor of the Ducks, and woke up in the middle of the Fourth to find they had run it up to a 49-21 lead. Apparently it was the most exciting offensive display I ever dozed to.

20. Arizona State - Split the Pac10 title with USC, but that absolutly pantsing by Texas drops them way low. If they can pass block next year, they should be damn good.

21. Hawaii - Oh, Warriors. Warriors, Warriors, Warriors. I stood up for you, I kept you ranked fairly high, I even took the position that you should be in the title game instead of LSU. And how do you repay my love? By refusing to block for Brennan the entire game and getting pantsed on a national stage after trying so desperately to make everyone believe you belonged there. But I just can't stay mad at you, so you will remain ranked.

22. Penn State - 9-4 and they won their bowl. Why not?

23. Virginia - Kind of a pity vote, but they did finish 9-4 in a season when no one thought they would get to a bowl, so whatever.

24. Mississippi State - I have to hand it to the Bulldogs. They overachieved into a 8-5 record with quality wins over Auburn, Kentucky, and Alabama, plus had a tremendous fourth quarter rally against Ole Miss to finish the regular season and held UCF to only three points in the kind of defensive struggle they've excelled at all season long.

25. Alabama - Say something, MFer. Say something.

Comment 8 comments  |  0 recs  | 

Do you like this story?

Comments

Display:

Over rating
Todd,

I notice that you continually put more importance on wins and losses, than the quality of the wins and losses.  I thought you would have changed your opinion after the Hawaii/UGA and LSU/OSU games.  Kansas has exactly one quality win in thirteen games.  I feel certain UGA would kill them.

As for the USC love not sure I still get it.  Can someone please tell me what quality win USC had?  They played a very mediocre schedule.  Their schedule actually made OSU's look competitive.  I guess that is what happens when your a name-brand school.

On another note I am really enjoying the list of the 5 disappointments (trying to say something positive)!

by kennybk483 on Jan 8, 2008 12:04 PM CST reply actions  

I'm not really sure where you are coming from...
...since I clearly took the quality of the wins and losses into account. Kansas not have what you consider "quality wins," but they did beat five bowl teams, including an absolute pantsing of Central Michigan, while their one loss was to Missouri, a very good team and a rival. Compare that to Georgia's two losses, one an absolute manhandling by a UT team that had no business beating them so badly and to a 6-6 South Carolina team that looked like they'd stolen UGA's playbook and gameplan weeks before kickoff. That's why I ranked KU over UGA, because they've played consistenly good football all season long while Georgia didn't. As for USC, they lost to a very good (with Dixon) Oregon team, but also lost to a piss terrible Stanford, which docked them below UGA. Still, they did beat the living daylights out of good Arizona State and Illinois teams.

by Todd on Jan 8, 2008 1:11 PM CST up reply actions  

I would put UGA #2
head to head contest UGA would beat KU.  I guess the UGA president also feels that way since he released a statement asking for a playoff.  This really goes to show how close UA is to being a real contender.  We went to OT with UGA and had LSU beat until late in the game.
I wouldn't piss off the boys from Alabama . . .

by I hate UT on Jan 8, 2008 12:55 PM CST reply actions  

Mizzou / OU
Missouri #6, Oklahoma #13?  With all respect due, I don't see how you can rank Mizzou ahead of OU when OU beat them twice.  

by Steve Dave on Jan 8, 2008 1:24 PM CST reply actions  

Because OU looked miserable against WFinV...
...and Mizzou dominated Arkansas. That's not to say Arkansas and West Virginia are comparable, because they are not, and I see your point and actually kind of agree now that I am thinking about it. Oh well.

by Todd on Jan 8, 2008 4:56 PM CST up reply actions  

Bama is a homer pick but this is what we do
Starting at the bottom, we really don't deserve to be ranked.Moving to the top, I 'd put Georgia #2, USC #3 kANSAS #4 and then OSU.

by baptman on Jan 8, 2008 6:15 PM CST reply actions  

Strength of schedule - UK and GA
Obviously, you don't know anything about strength of schedule in regard to UK and GA.  GA's SOS is 6, UK's is 60.  Thats not even close.  And when your signature win is a "pantsing" (whatever that is) of Central Michigan...well thats just laughable (on multiple levels!).

by carolinadawg on Jan 10, 2008 6:02 PM CST reply actions  

So what you're saying...
...is that holding an 8-4 team that averages 34.79 points per game to SEVEN points, 447 yards per game to 294 points, and held the #11 QB in the nation to his lowest yardage of the season and only 1 TD, all while also scoring 52 points is nothing to talk about? Or, I don't know, beating Va. Tech in the Orange Bowl? Or, I don't know, losing to South Carolina? No, wait, that was Georgia. I see why you're bitter.

by Todd on Jan 10, 2008 6:13 PM CST up reply actions  

Comments For This Post Are Closed


User Tools

Welcome to the SB Nation blog covering the Alabama Crimson Tide.

FanPosts

Community blog posts and discussion.

Recommended FanPosts

Sg_head_small
The Time A Kentucky Fan Saved Me From Being Raped and Murdered

Recent FanPosts

Crystal_ball_small
Driving While Asian
Small
New Saftey Rules Suggested by Bama Opponents
57lsu_small
RBR " Don't Forget About Hoops" Random 10
Fum_small
OT: Anyone running in the Mercedes-Benz Marathon?
Small
AP/ESPN saying the Big 10 considering a Plus One
Th_squidbillies_small
The Curious Journey of Philon
Mewanee_3_men_in_a_tub_after_small
2012 Post-Signing Day Projected Defensive Depth Chart
Woodymugshot1_small
RBR Random 10
Script-a_small
Recruiting - Looking at who went where - by State

+ New FanPost All FanPosts >

Roll Bama Roll on Twitter


Managers

Disreputable_small Todd

Miltonf-788904_small outsidethesidelines

Kyp2_small Nico2.0

Editors

Kleph_logo_copy_small kleph

Green_small Matt Dover