Roll 'Bama Roll: An SB Nation Community

Navigation: Jump to content areas:


Sports blogs for fans, by fans.
New Blog: World Soccer Digest for Soccer Fans!

Player Thoughts From The A-Day Game

I'm going to separate the posts on the A-Day game into two different posts, one is going to focus on general thoughts, while the other is going to focus on thoughts about individual players and their progress and development. We'll go with the latter first, so here goes:

  • John Parker Wilson had a solid, even if not spectacular, day. He looked improved slightly from a year ago, and noticeably threw the football away better, and also got into the check-downs better than what we saw a year ago. I don't think there is any evidence to indicate he is going to have a breakout senior campaign, but he looked solid and improved.
  • Greg McElroy looked "good" based on the standards that he had set in the first two scrimmages. He made a couple of nice throws, and by that I explicitly mean three or four. He didn't play particularly well, but he didn't look ungodly terrible, which is apparently how he performed in the first two scrimmages. Unfortunately, there's still not a lot of positives to talk about with him. He doesn't have a strong arm, he's not particularly accurate, and he holds onto the ball so long sometimes you would swear he's clinging to a life jacket in the middle of the Atlantic.
  • Nick Fanuzzi looked completely out of his league. He has nice size and a nice arm, but aside from that... it's not pretty. He missed several open receivers, and in particular he overthrew a wide open route over the middle that should have been an easy touchdown, and in fact overthrew it so bad it turned into an easy pick in the back of the end zone for Rashad Johnson. As unimpressive as McElroy looked, Fanuzzi looked much worse.
  • Thomas Darrah is the second best quarterback we have on this team, end of story. He has great size, and he has a very big arm. He's more physically impressive than even Wilson. I know he is still in Saban's doghouse for an arrest a few months back, but if you go on pure performance, he is easily the second best quarterback on the roster. I know he's a walk-on, but he's far from typical walk-on. Sufficed to say, you don't find many 6'5 walk-on quarterbacks with rocket arms. We should all be keeping our eye on this kid.
  • Terry Grant is not an every-down back, and I've said that on many occasions. I think he showcased that yesterday, he's really a scatback and cannot run between the tackles. He's going to have to get his opportunities that you would typically expect from a scatback, and he's going to have to develop that into a third-down back who can pass block and catch the ball out of the backfield. Fortunately for Grant, and us, he did both of those latter two things really well on Saturday. And that is key for the amount of playing time Grant is going to get this Fall.
  • Roy Upchurch started off quite nicely, and he did show some signs of an ability to run between the tackles. Unfortunately, he seemingly faded off late in the game, only further calling into question his consistency, which has always been the big question with him. Either way, though, he's had a nice Spring and should be noted as such.
  • Nick Walker... developed into such a good receiving threat at tight end... still can't protect the football.
  • Colin Peek had a good day, despite a drop, and was running with the first team. I doubt his appeal goes through with the NCAA, so he likely won't be able to play this Fall, but he's a fine football player and a very good receiver. I figure he is just as good as Nick Walker, and perhaps a bit better. That bodes well when Walker graduates and Peek becomes eligible in 2009.
  • Mike McCoy is really breaking out, and his Spring has surprised me. He was never anything remotely close to a deep threat last year, but he has changed that this season, and looked very good yesterday. He looks to have made as much progress as anyone.
  • Darius Hanks looked as good as advertised. He might not technically "start," but he's going to play a lot, and get a lot of catches. He wasn't a highly-touted player, but he is obviously a fine player.
  • Earl Alexander looked really nice. When he got to Alabama, he had a lot of progress to make fundamentally at wide receiver because he had never played the position before. Going into his third years, he's developing very nicely. He's a physical beast at roughly 6'5 and over 215 pounds, and he is making strides on the fundamental side. He will play a lot in 2008, and catch a lot of balls. It's hard not to be highly optimistic when thinking of his future.
  • Marquis Maze showcased some of the true athleticism and physical nature that gets you excited about his future. He is obviously a highly talented athlete, and he's a physical player too. He had a long touchdown catch where he smoked a defensive back, had another nice reception on a crossing route, and blocked well in the running game. I don't think it would be entirely fair to compare anyone to Tyrone Prothro, but I would be lying if I were to say that he didn't remind me of him in many ways. He's small, but highly athletic, and he plays tough as nails.
  • Mike Johnson looked like he has made the transition to left guard quite nicely. I've said on several occasions that is a natural guard anyway, and it showed yesterday. He looked good in the running game, and his pass blocking looked much better when not having to face the highly athletic edge rushers at defensive end. At the very least, you can write it in the books that he will be an upgrade over Justin Britt.
  • Drew Davis has obviously made some nice progress at right tackle. He was one I was really keeping my eye on, and he looked fairly impressive. He doesn't look overly special, but he generally looked fairly solid. At the very least, he's made a ton of progress this Spring. I still expect Tyler Love to come in and take the starting job at right tackle, but Davis will fight him hard, and in the end give us some quality depth.
  • Lorenzo Washington had another nice day at nose tackle. He's not a big guy, but he does have great quickness and burst off the snap, and it pays huge dividends. He's honestly a natural 3-4 end, but he's a pretty stout tackle in his own right.
  • Alfred McCullough was highly impressive to me. He's a big kid, and very quick. You can go ahead and write it down now, he's going to play a lot this Fall. He may not technically "start" -- I figure that distinction goes to Greenwood -- but he and Greenwood will split snaps almost evenly, and he will be featured in every major game we play. He has been one of the major surprises of the Spring.
  • Josh Chapman is an absolute load at nose tackle. He is listed as 6'1, and that's a total crock. I'd be a bit surprised if he were even 6'0, he's probably more like 5'10 or 5'11. Still, though, that kid is stout as can be. He is very strong, and he has nice quickness, plus his lack of height helps him out with pad level. I was very encouraged by his development this Spring, and he looks to be right on the same level with Washington. I think he'll split snaps with Lorenzo almost evenly.
  • Luther Davis has a lot of progress to make. It's great to have him back on campus, but he has a lot of work to do in the weight room. He had a pretty big gut, and he was honestly the biggest of all of the guys going through the defensive line drills. I think his lack of conditioning is probably his biggest problem right now.
  • Eryk Anders was a big surprise on defense. He looked very good rushing the passer off the edge, and really looked to have improve. He's bulked up a fair amount, but is still quite fast. We should keep an eye on him.
  • Jimmy Johns... He looked okay, and by that I mean just okay. When he hits you, it's like you got hit by a freight train, but that's not what it is all about. He still has a long way to go on the mental side of things, and looked to be confused on a few occasions. And he was seemingly always the first to come off of the field when we went to nickel packages. He's great physically, but mentally he still has a ways to go.
  • Jennings Hester was absolutely smoked by Grant on the shallow crossing route that turned into a 75-yard touchdown. I know he's young, but he's not big, and he is obviously not very fast. Makes you wonder...
  • Chavis Williams looked pretty impressive. He is a nice physical specimen, and you can tell he has been working hard in the weight room. I wouldn't expect a whole lot out of him in the interim, but for the long-term I think he's a good prospect.
  • Justin Woodall... eh, I don't know. I want to see this kid do well -- particularly considering the MLB contract he gave up to come to Alabama -- but I just don't know at this point. He has obviously gotten a starting job locked up at the end of Spring, but realistically we really have no one behind him. He's essentially won the job by default. I was looking at him a good bit on Saturday, and honestly wasn't too impressed. I really cannot recall any play in which he really stood out and impressed me. He's probably looking better than Marcus Carter at this point, but at this rate I don't see him holding off Mark Barron for long.
  • Rashad Johnson looked good, and has had a nice Spring. He has obviously added some weight, but is still extremely athletic. As long as he stays healthy, I imagine he will be on the All-SEC teams, and will probably be playing on Sunday this time next year.
  • Marquis Johnson has developed nicely as well. He's bulked up a good bit since we saw last him last year against FSU, and overall just seems to be a better player. I doubt he starts this Fall, but he will provide some quality depth. He went out during the game with a mild concussion, but he is seemingly going to be fine.
  • P.J. Fitzgerald had a nice yard per punt average, but still looked pretty shaky. He had a couple of nice punts, but by the same token he almost had a couple of short punts that happened to roll a long way. Obviously there were no returns allowed in the game, and I have a feeling those two short ones would have probably been caught in a live game situation, and dramatically decreased his average. I think he's made some progress over a year ago, but we still have a long way to go in the punting game.
  • Leigh Tiffin looked good, and nailed a pretty long field goal. He also looked considerably improved when it comes to kick-offs. At the very least, it's nice to have such a consistent kicker on the roster, and one with good range as well. I think he has the potential to be the best place-kicker we've had at Alabama since Michael Proctor.

0 recs  |  Comment 20 comments

Story-email Email Printer Print

Comments

Display:

Cornhole Reamer
Reamer had a good solid game Saturday and I think we're going to hear his name a lot come fall.  

On an unrelated note, for some reason I have an urge to purchase some pvc stripes even though I have absolutely no use for them.  Strange.

by JR on Apr 14, 2008 10:02 AM CDT reply actions   0 recs

Its
great to see that we are developing some depth at D-line. As Bamagrad has stated, the D-line is VERY important to the effectiveness of the 3-4, especially to the LB's. To see that we have multiple guys able to rotate in and out is very uplifting.

by bammer on Apr 14, 2008 11:01 AM CDT reply actions   0 recs

Defensive depth
Really worries me.  OTL brings up some good examples where we may have a strong player backing up our starter.  But, the performance of the 2nd string in Saturday's game makes me worry that we may have a pretty steep drop between 1st and 2nd string on the defensive side of the ball overall.  Am I wrong?  Will we have to fill the holes with recruits this Fall?
BamaFrazier

by BamaFrazier on Apr 14, 2008 11:32 AM CDT reply actions   0 recs

We'll probably have...
...decent depth on the line and in the secondary, and the incoming freshmen will bolster that, but the LBs are just not there.

by Todd on Apr 14, 2008 12:34 PM CDT up reply actions   0 recs

Which means
the middle of the field may be wide open and any decent OC will exploit that all day long.

by alextuscaloosa on Apr 14, 2008 12:41 PM CDT reply actions   0 recs

Not necessarily...
...we can always play a lot of nickel and dime sets since Marquis Johnson seems to have improved a good bit since his unfortunate showing against FSU. Reamer is a converted safety and should be able to play that shallow coverage midfield, and I would imagine Johns will be the odd man out with extra DBs on the field, leaving room for Johnson (or Arenas, or whoever is the nickelback) to play the flats like an OLB would in coverage.

by Todd on Apr 14, 2008 1:02 PM CDT up reply actions   0 recs

The good news...
The good news is that since the spread offense dominates the SEC now-a-days -- even though a bunch of the talking heads haven't caught on yet -- you really don't use linebackers quite as much as you used to. These days, with offenses spreading the field with three to five receivers, you generally find yourself in nickel and dime packages more than anything else.

Basically, being short, it really helps you out if you don't have great linebackers, because you are so often taking one or two of those linebackers off the field and replacing them with DB's.

Don't get me wrong, you still need good linebackers, but that trend does help mitigate the problems that come with our struggles at the position. I'm much less worried about it now than I would be, say, 20 years ago in the SEC.

by outsidethesidelines on Apr 14, 2008 8:35 PM CDT up reply actions   0 recs

Anyone else eat BBQ Nachos
Saturday?  I did and got sick as a dog.  We went to look for Big Bad Wolf BBQ but they weren't there, so we settled for another place.

I started puking on the way home, and have been sick and in bed since Saturday afternoon.

And, uhh, yeah, the lb worries me too..

"FAILURE" - When your best just isn't good enough

by BamaReturns07 on Apr 14, 2008 1:35 PM CDT reply actions   0 recs

Big Bad Wolf's...
...needs to set up shop 24/7 in Tuscaloosa.
Roll Tide!

by Nico2.0 on Apr 14, 2008 11:11 PM CDT up reply actions   0 recs

This year
our defense will be in the same position our offense was in last year: one or two injuries/suspensions away from falling apart.

I think this also shows how long it really takes to build a team.  We almost have a complete offense, but we have holes in defense.  In 2009 we'll have a strong defense, but we'll have a new QB on offense.  By 2010, maybe we'll be exactly where we want to be.  That's Saban's fourth year.  

Saban-haters always talk about how he only had one really good season at LSU (I don't buy it, but they say it), but if you look at it, he didn't ever get to coach his most complete teams.  By this I mean that 2003's National Championship was a bit of a surprise.  But the 2005, 2006, and 2007 teams would have been the culmination of his work.  They were loaded with talent and projected to do great things before they ever took the field.

With a team like this, I think you'd really see what Saban is capable of, just as you saw in 2003.  Hopefully we'll have a complete team soon, that's so good on paper all we have to worry about it is executing on the field.

by Bamagrad on Apr 14, 2008 1:50 PM CDT reply actions   0 recs

Reamer-good player even better name
As in that receiver just got "reamered"

In the trash time, some conerback named Ballou seemed to be around the ball alot.

Arenas looked OK, but his lack of height was challenged all day and exploited several times.  My starting reciever rotation would be Stover, McCoy/Jones and Hanks in the slot.

After A-day, I think Finebaum is correct in predicting a 8-4 season with a win over the Barn.  8-4 wouldn't suprise me but I am hopeful that we will beat UT or LSU for a 9-3 season.

by heffie on Apr 14, 2008 3:30 PM CDT reply actions   0 recs

I'll Take It
As much as I hate to say it, if you offer me an 8-win season with a victory over The Barn, I would take it and give you change.  I just can not stand losing to them anymore.  The Barners are getting totally out of hand, and I need us to beat them so they will shut the hell up, go back under their rocks, and show once again what fair-weather fans they are.
BamaFrazier

by BamaFrazier on Apr 15, 2008 11:41 AM CDT up reply actions   0 recs

Questions
OTS or anyone else who knows.

What is the story on Darrah? I've seen his name a few times, but who is he?

How did Huber look? Can he help at all at LB?

Can this Smith kid not punt? I would have thought he would have been able to beat out PJ. If PJ punts again this year we are in trouble.  

 

by 5026 on Apr 14, 2008 7:41 PM CDT reply actions   0 recs

Answers...
Darrah was a first-team All-State QB as a junior in Georgia. I don't know if he had a bad senior season or was hurt or whatever, but he only had offers from the likes of Tulane, Kent State, etc. Rivals had him as a two-star, but he didn't have an attractive offer list. I really don't know what his deal was. Obviously he has talent, I mean you don't just find 6'5 quarterbacks with rocket arms every day.

Huber looked good in a limited role. He won't play on passing downs because of a lack of athleticism, but he is a tough, physical guy who could do very well in short-yardage situations. He might not play that much early in 2008, but I'd bet we will get more production out of him at LB than FB.

Smith apparently got a look at punter, but no one knows for now. He's been kind of quiet, and honestly that is expected for a true freshman who is enrolling early. We will find out more about him come later in Fall camp.

by outsidethesidelines on Apr 14, 2008 8:20 PM CDT up reply actions   0 recs

Thanks
for the answers. I know Smith is a freshman but in punting it is not like he has to learn a play book etc. I was really hoping he would be able to help here.

by 5026 on Apr 15, 2008 8:31 AM CDT up reply actions   0 recs

Something i just thought about
there are about three or four players on a football team whose names you'd just rather not know. the long snapper, the holder, the punter, and the place kicker. If you're every day fan can name any of those players, you've got a problem.

by alextuscaloosa on Apr 14, 2008 8:10 PM CDT reply actions   0 recs

I disagree....
...about the punter and place kicker. All four things you listed are crucial, but field position battles in tight games can be won or lost with a punter and goodness knows what a kicker can do for you. I'm probably weird though in that I know the punters and kickers for a lot of different teams.
Roll Tide!

by Nico2.0 on Apr 14, 2008 11:14 PM CDT up reply actions   0 recs

Critical Yes,
but when they do their jobs, the side walk fans don't really notice, but when they consistantly kick short punts, miss field goals, and bobble snaps thats when they get noticed. I guess thats what i meant.

by alextuscaloosa on Apr 15, 2008 12:25 AM CDT up reply actions   0 recs

You're just...
...sticking up for your fellow soccer players, Nico.  Fraggin' communist!  

Kidding aside, I agree with Nico (and the Nicktator) that these positions can win and lose ballgames.  But like alextuscaloosa said, the average fan usually only remembers "The Single-Bar Facemasked Ones" when they screw up.  

Here's to you, Reggie Roby:

http://pyleoflist.com/?p=311

by Bubba Chang on Apr 15, 2008 9:29 AM CDT up reply actions   0 recs

I never...
...thought of it in that context, but I suppose it's somewhat true. If it weren't for soccer though we'd likely still be enduring straight ahead kickers!
Roll Tide!

by Nico2.0 on Apr 15, 2008 9:59 AM CDT up reply actions   0 recs

Comments For This Post Are Closed


User Tools

Welcome to the SB Nation blog covering the Alabama Crimson Tide.
Start posting about the Crimson Tide »

Join SB Nation and dive into communities focused on all your favorite teams.

FanPosts

Community blog posts and discussion.

Recommended FanPosts

Miltonf-788904_small
The Tennessee-Chattanooga Open Thread
Kleph_logo_copy_small
Tennessee Correctional League Recruiting Heats Up
Miltonf-788904_small
The Mississippi State Open Thread
Furman_bisher_small
The Story of a College Football Fix
Small
Byes: why the huge discrepancy?

Recent FanPosts

Bear-bryant_small
Tide-Mocs prediction thread
Bkc_ala_dudley164x225_1__small
MBB: Alabama 86, Jackson State 69
Alabama_crimson_tide_small
How in the heck do you cook edible gator????
Cimg9132_small
They should know better
Script_small
Lawyer for AU student, Jenkins, that Eric Smith assaulted on Finebaum
Belgian_2020a_20crest_201_small
From The National Weather Center
Saban_small
Todd's Taste of the Town
Bear-bryant_small
Good article RE: Bowl system is the fairest way of crowning a NC
Alfred_e
There seems to be a lot of reference to BAMA and Star Wars

+ New FanPost All FanPosts >

Roll Bama Roll on Twitter


Managers

Large_hankwilliams_small Todd

Miltonf-788904_small outsidethesidelines

Nickcave_small Nico2.0

Authors

Kleph_logo_copy_small kleph

26935420b_small PeteHoliday

Official Partner of CBS Sports