The McPhee is out. It's the end of an era.
Neither of these nominees holds anything for me, but I voted for McAdams since she's more of a sweetheart than Biel. I mean, Biel is smoking hot, don't get me wrong, but any idiot can post a bunch of pictures of a smoking hot chick to drool over. We're looking for someone to fall in love with here at RBR, because we're romantic like that. Just so long as we are falling in love with Brittany Snow (or maybe Minka Kelly or, to a lesser extent, Rachel Bilson). Updated bracket after the jump.